What is a common misconception people have about happiness?
A common misconception about happiness is that it means being satisfied with everything. That is not true. In fact, it may be one of the more damaging ideas we carry. It suggests that if we are truly happy, we should be undisturbed by grief, injustice, disappointment, illness, or the suffering of others. It turns happiness into a kind of denial. Smile more. Look on the bright side. Count your blessings. Move on.
Kate Bowler has written powerfully about the Western obsession with health, wealth, and happiness. Her work is compelling because it does not come from a distance. As a cancer survivor, she writes from both lived experience and cultural analysis. She understands how easily our culture reaches for platitudes when life becomes too hard to explain.
The problem with our obsession with happiness is that it often becomes individualistic. It focuses on my wellbeing, my comfort, my fulfilment, my capacity to remain cheerful. It can cut us off from the pain of others. Worse, it can leave us with no real language for suffering when it finally comes close to us.
When someone is grieving, we do not need to rush them toward cheerfulness. When someone is afraid, we do not need to shame them for lacking faith. When someone is angry at injustice, we do not need to tell them to calm down. Some emotions are appropriate to the situation.
Kate Bowler quotes psychologist Lisa Damour, who offers a wonderfully freeing definition of mental health. Mental health is not the ability to feel happy all the time. It is the ability to feel what is appropriate. Fear after a traffic accident makes sense. Sadness when remembering a friend who suffered makes sense. Anger in the face of cruelty makes sense. There is no virtue in feeling the wrong thing just because it looks more positive.
This is where joy becomes a richer and more meaningful concept than happiness. Happiness is often imagined as ease, comfort, pleasure, or satisfaction. Joy is deeper. Joy can live in the same room as sorrow. Joy does not require everything to be fixed. It does not ask us to deny pain, avoid grief, or pretend the world is better than it is. Joy is not the absence of sadness. It is the presence of something strong enough to hold sadness without being destroyed by it.
Joy does not mean pretending the world is fine. It does not mean withdrawing from concern, ignoring injustice, or becoming emotionally unavailable to the pain of others. You can be content and still grieve. You can be grateful and still protest. You can know joy and still carry sorrow. You can have hope and still tell the truth. In fact, perhaps that is the only kind of hope worth having.
Contentment is learning to live with gratitude without making peace with everything that is wrong. And joy, when it comes, is not a reward for having escaped suffering. It is the grace of finding that life can still be meaningful, beautiful, and shared in all of life’s experiences.
Joyful, anyway.
The Afterword 
Leave a comment